Briefing · UK · 2026

Fees are not donations: Gift Aid records where a charity also charges for classes

HMRC's Gift Aid guidance says payments for tuition are not gifts, and that every claim needs an audit trail from each donation to a valid declaration. Charities that take fees and donations through the same channels have to keep the two apart.

Diagram: four ways money arrives at a charity that also runs classes (online form, payment link, direct debit, cash at the office) feed one mixed list. A fork separates fees, which are not Gift Aid donations, from donations, which need a traceable declaration. Below, the three things HMRC's guidance expects for each claim, and a general checklist that is not from the guidance.

What was published

HMRC’s detailed guidance on Gift Aid, Chapter 3 of its guidance notes for charities (last updated in July 2026), sets out what counts as a donation and what a charity has to keep to support a claim. Three points matter for any charity that also charges for what it teaches.

  • A fee is not a gift. Payments in return for services, rights or goods are not gifts, and school fees paid for a particular pupil are one of the guidance’s examples (3.4.6). In its words, “the payment of fees to a charity is not a gift to charity” (3.34).
  • Every claim needs a trail. A charity must keep records that link each donation to an identifiable donor who has made a valid declaration (3.27.1). The declaration has to give the donor’s name and home address, name the charity, cover the gifts and explain the tax position to the donor (3.6.2). Copying details from a form into a database is not, on its own, a record that the donor made the declaration (3.7.2).
  • Records are kept for years. Depending on how the charity is set up, records are kept for up to six years after the period they relate to, and for as long as an ongoing declaration is in use (3.30). Where records are not good enough, the declaration can be treated as invalid and the tax repaid, with interest and possibly penalties (3.8.1).

Why it matters for schools, madrasahs and academies

Many charities that teach also fundraise: weekend and evening madrasahs, supplementary schools, online academies, mosque education departments. Families pay a monthly or termly fee, and the same families give to an appeal or a building fund, often through the same website, the same payment provider and sometimes the same direct debit.

When a fee and a gift arrive through one channel, someone has to decide later which was which, usually from a bank statement. That decision becomes the basis of the claim. A fee claimed by mistake is tax to repay. A gift without a declaration that can be traced is a claim the charity cannot support.

What to check

  • List every place money arrives (online form, payment link, direct debit, cash at the office) and say, for each, whether it takes fees, donations or both.
  • Give donations their own reference, one that never appears on a fee.
  • Pick one recent claim and time how long it takes to go from a single donation to the declaration the donor actually gave.
  • Know where declarations are stored, who can change them, and whether you have ever restored them from a backup.
  • Decide what happens to a declaration when a family stops paying fees but keeps giving.
  • Put a date in the diary to delete records once the retention period has passed.

This note summarises HMRC’s published guidance. Fairlead Systems has no connection with it, and it is not tax advice: check the full guidance, or ask an adviser, before changing how you claim.

Fairlead Systems was not involved in the events described here. The account above is drawn only from the sources listed, which were last checked on 17 October 2026. If you spot an error, write to us and we will correct it.

Insights

More from the public record

Recognise this pattern?

Tell us what the process looks like today. We will say whether it needs fixing, and how small the fix can be.