From the public record · Northern Ireland · 2023

What you cannot see in a file is still in the file

In 2023 a spreadsheet released under Freedom of Information contained a hidden tab with details of 9,483 police officers and staff. The ICO said simple internal processes could have prevented it.

A spreadsheet shows a harmless summary tab; next to it a hidden tab named Sheet2 contains the surnames, initials, ranks and roles of 9,483 officers and staff. The ICO fine was £750,000.

What happened

In August 2023 the Police Service of Northern Ireland released a spreadsheet in response to a Freedom of Information request. A hidden tab in the file contained the surnames, initials, ranks and roles of 9,483 officers and staff.

The Information Commissioner’s Office fined the service £750,000, noting that the figure would otherwise have been £5.6 million. The Commissioner said the breach came from “a lack of simple, internal processes” and described it as a lesson for all organisations.

The pattern

Releasing a file is often a manual step at the end of a long process. It depends on one person noticing something that the file format is designed not to show: hidden sheets, filtered rows, comments, document properties.

The people doing this work are often not data specialists, and responses are usually prepared against a deadline. That combination makes a missed tab more likely, not less.

What a proportionate fix looks like

Diagram: before release, a file is automatically flattened and stripped of hidden sheets, filtered rows, comments and properties; a plain summary of its contents is produced and a second person signs it off.
An automatic gate in front of the existing release process. Example counts.

A short automated step before anything leaves the organisation: the file is converted to a flat format, hidden content and metadata are removed, and a second person signs off a plain summary of what the file actually contains. It does not replace the existing process. It puts a gate in front of it.

Any team that publishes or releases data, including FOI, transparency returns and data shared with partners, can apply the same check.

The check takes seconds and runs the same way every time, whoever is on shift, and the summary it produces becomes a record of exactly what was released.

Questions worth asking

  • Who checks a file before it leaves the organisation, and what exactly do they check?
  • Are files ever released in the same format they were worked on in?
  • Do we know what hidden sheets, comments or properties our usual templates contain?
  • Is there a record of what was released, to whom and when?

Fairlead Systems was not involved in the events described here. The account above is drawn only from the sources listed, which were last checked on 1 October 2026. If you spot an error, write to us and we will correct it.

Insights

More from the public record

Recognise this pattern?

Tell us what the process looks like today. We will say whether it needs fixing, and how small the fix can be.