Briefing · UK · 2025–2026

Changing provider: the transition is not the test, go-live is

The National Audit Office is investigating the transfer of Civil Service Pension Scheme administration to Capita, after key service levels were repeatedly missed despite a two-year transition.

Timeline from the NAO's description: a two-year transition period, Capita taking over from MyCSP on 1 December 2025, key service levels repeatedly missed after go-live, and £22.1 million in support loans to more than 3,900 members by August 2026. Below, a general checklist of what ready can mean before a switch.

What was published

In early October 2026 the National Audit Office announced an investigation into how the Cabinet Office managed the change of administrator for the Civil Service Pension Scheme. Capita took over administration from MyCSP on 1 December 2025, under a contract worth £239 million over seven years.

The NAO says that, despite a two-year transition period, Capita has struggled to administer the scheme effectively since the transfer, and that key service levels have been repeatedly missed. The Cabinet Office introduced transitional support loans for affected members: £22.1 million had been paid to more than 3,900 members by August 2026.

The investigation will look at the state of the scheme at go-live, Capita’s performance and the Cabinet Office’s oversight. The NAO expects to report in winter 2026/27, so its findings are not yet known, and nothing here anticipates them.

Why it matters beyond this case

Every change of provider or system has the same moment: the old arrangement stops and the new one has to work at full volume on day one. That is as true for a charity moving its supporter database or a small firm changing accounting software as for a national scheme. Time spent preparing is not proof of readiness. Only measured performance is.

What to check before you switch

  • Write “ready” down as numbers: items handled per day, response times, the largest acceptable backlog.
  • Test at real daily volume, not with a sample.
  • Count the records that leave the old system and arrive in the new one, and explain any difference before go-live.
  • Decide in advance what happens if the numbers are not met: delay, move in phases, or keep the old route running for a period.

Fairlead Systems was not involved in the events described here. The account above is drawn only from the sources listed, which were last checked on 2 October 2026. If you spot an error, write to us and we will correct it.

Insights

More from the public record

Recognise this pattern?

Tell us what the process looks like today. We will say whether it needs fixing, and how small the fix can be.